**Bennett Kaspar-Williams, who identifies as non-binary and uses he/him and they/them pronouns, gave birth to son Hudson via cesarean section in October 2020 with husband Malik.** Despite marking male on medical forms and presenting as male after beginning transition in 2014 (including top surgery), hospital nurses repeatedly referred to him as the mother rather than the father.

The experience left Kaspar-Williams distressed. He told the New York Post that being called “mom” ignored both his stated identity and the paperwork he had completed. The incident, first reported in 2021 and later republished, underscored the gap between institutional language and patients’ self-identification.

Kaspar-Williams argued that pregnancy and motherhood should not be treated as automatically linked to womanhood. He noted that having a uterus does not guarantee the ability to conceive or carry a child, and that equating the two creates a false standard that excludes many people.

His account highlights ongoing friction in medical settings over gender language during childbirth and the broader push to separate biological capacity from gender identity.